Stockholm university

Research project Negotiating care, post-trafficking needs and gender in understanding help-seeking behaviour (...)

(...) of trafficked victims: a case study of Finland and Sweden

This is a comparative case study, which seeks to investigate help-seeking behaviour among the male and female victims of human trafficking in Sweden and Finland. Using the post-trafficking assistance model as an analytical framework, this study aims to uncover factors that enable or impede help-seeking behaviour among trafficked victims, as well as to identify the gaps in existing assistance mechanisms in the two countries. Through ethnographic methods, combining insights from sociology, medical anthropology and criminology, this study attempts to gather detailed qualitative data to examine the help-seeking behaviour of trafficked victims. This study is grounded in the constructionist tradition, whereby it attempts to examine the existing assistance and care mechanisms and the actual needs of victims through an interactional lens. It then attempts to identify the role of these factors in the help-seeking behaviour of trafficked victims. In analysing the empirical data, I will  build on an interactional approach to victimhood, and draw from theories regarding the hierarchy of victimhood, the concept of the ideal victim and notions of gender (including the sociology of femininity and masculinity).

Project description

This study is an intervention into the victimological scholarship. It aims to uncover how the interactional process of assigning the victim status and the socially constructed meaning of gender affect the help-seeking behaviour of trafficked victims. Human trafficking is defined as a violation of fundamental human rights and it is classified as a crime in domestic and international law the world over. However, the makeup of the anti-trafficking legal frameworks, their practical implementation and the broader social understanding of the crime vary across the different historical and socio-economic environments. This also impacts the way post-trafficking assistance services are shaped. Comparing two countries that differ in their anti-trafficking approaches and detected victim composition will allow for a deeper understanding of the factors that enable or impede help-seeking behaviour among trafficked victims. For this reason, two Nordic countries (with differing anti-trafficking approaches and  victim characteristics) have been chosen: Finland and Sweden. The current legal frameworks in both countries cover all forms of trafficking indicated in the UN Trafficking in Persons Protocol (the document that provided the first internationally acknowledged definition of human trafficking). However, to date, while in Finland the forms of exploitation and gender of the victims vary, the vast majority of detected cases in Sweden comprise female victims of sexual exploitation. This difference in itself makes the comparison of these two countries an interesting approach. Moreover, while there is an abundance of scholarship on the trafficking experience of female victims, the academic consideration of trafficking in males is far less common. Considering Sweden’s relatively limited experience in identifying male victims, Finland allows for a more even representation of both gender groups in the study. Previous studies on human trafficking have illuminated the problems of misidentification and self-misidentification related to the interactional practice of assigning the victim status to the trafficked population. The difficulties in detecting victims of human trafficking obstruct access to justice and, by extension, post-trafficking care services. In events where victims have been identified, access to post-trafficking care services can be an arduous process filled with a number of personal, societal and legal barriers. 

This research involves an ethnographic case study that examines the help-seeking behaviour of victims of human trafficking through an investigation of gendered legal and social constructions of victimhood and the lived experiences of trafficked victims in Finland and Sweden. Following a constructionist approach, this study will explore the nature of help-seeking behaviour of trafficked victims by analysing the construction of human trafficking as a social problem and by taking an interactional approach to victimology, where I will look at victimization as a social process through which individuals are assigned the victim status.

The ultimate aim of this study is to investigate how assumptions about victimhood and gender affect the help-seeking behaviour of trafficked victims in Finland and Sweden, using the post-trafficking assistance model as an analytical framework. 

Post-trafficking assistance model (Smiragina-Ingelstrom, 2020)
Post-trafficking assistance model (Smiragina-Ingelstrom, 2020)

 

Project members

Project managers

Publications

Smiragina P.A. (2013).

‘Human Trafficking, Forced Labor and Labor Exploitation’, Migration Bridges in Eurasia. V International Conference: Labour Migration in the Russian Federation: The Prevention of Forced Labour, the Promotion of Social Economical Development, Improvement Regulation, Russian Academy of Science, Moscow, p. 229-232.

Smiragina, P. (2015).

‘Misidentification of Men Within the Human Trafficking Discourse’. Refereed Proceedings of TASA 2015 Conference: Neoliberalism and Contemporary Challenges for the Asia Pacific, The Australian Sociological Association, p. 123-129.

Smiragina, P. (2015).

‘The Invisibility of Male Victims of Human Trafficking’. NEXUS, Australian Sociological Association, vol. 27, no 1, p. 39-40.

Smiragina, P. (2017).

‘Fear and Choice within the Framework of Exploitation Research’. NSfK’s 59th Research Seminar Report, p.303-312.

Smiragina, P. (2019).

‘Trafficking in Persons for the Purpose of Organ Removal’. NSfK’s 61st Research Seminar Report.

Wilkins, D. & Smiragina-Ingelstrom P. (Forthcoming).

’The Problem of “Slavery” and Enslavement: Modern Discourses on the Problems of Slavery Past and Present’. In: Wilkins, D. & Smiragina-Ingelstrom P.(eds) Slavery in Transition: Critical Studies of Slavery and Enslavement Over Time. Leiden, The Netherlands: Brill.

Schoultz, I. & Smiragina-Ingelström, P.

’Access to social rights for victims of trafficking and labour exploitation in Sweden’. In Piilgaard Porner Nielsen, S. & Hammerslev, O. (eds) European Welfare Rights in Practice: Regulation, Professionals, and Citizens. London: Palgrave Macmillan. (Forthcoming).